Retailer region: Some links in this guide open Amazon.com (U.S.), as checked on 16 September 2026. A U.S. listing does not confirm Canadian delivery, Canadian-dollar pricing or the same local model. Check the destination, currency, delivery and return terms before ordering.
Choose adjustable dumbbells by the loads you actually use, the size of each weight step, the space needed for both bases and the cost of a complete pair. A large maximum weight is not useful if the smallest setting is too heavy or the next step is too large for your exercises.
Recall correction — September 15, 2026: We have withdrawn our recommendation for the original BowFlex SelectTech 552. BowFlex and the U.S. CPSC identify original 552 and 1090 adjustable dumbbells with plates that can detach during use. If you own an affected unit, stop using it and follow the manufacturer’s recall instructions. The linked remedy describes U.S. purchases; Canadian owners should contact BowFlex or their seller for the applicable local process. Do not confuse original recalled models with newer Results Series replacements.
Read BowFlex’s model identification and recall instructions
Research basis: This is a comparison of buying criteria and published product information, not a hands-on durability test. Exact variants, included quantities, prices and Canadian warranty coverage must match the listing you select.
Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, DealScanOn may earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
| Option | Decision to make | Check before ordering |
|---|---|---|
| Original BowFlex SelectTech 552 | Recommendation withdrawn | Identify recalled model; see official notice |
| PowerBlock Elite EXP | Do you need a compatible future expansion? | Exact generation, expansion kit compatibility and pair contents |
| NordicTrack Select-A-Weight | Does the adjustment sequence suit your routine? | Minimum setting, increments, handle clearance and tray dimensions |
| ATIVAFIT adjustable models | Does this exact variant meet your load requirements? | Single versus pair, weight range and Canadian returns |
1. Bowflex SelectTech 552 Adjustable Dumbbells

Original model: recall check required
The previous best-overall verdict has been removed. The image identifies the previously discussed product and is not a purchase recommendation. Use the recall link above before considering any original SelectTech 552 listing.
2. PowerBlock Elite EXP

Check the expansion path
An expandable set may suit someone who expects to outgrow the starting range. Confirm that the exact Elite EXP generation supports the expansion kit you intend to buy; similar product names are not proof of compatibility.
Key Features
- 5 to 50 lbs (expandable)
- Compact design
- Check handle clearance and selector instructions
Pros
- Potential to retain the same base set when adding a compatible expansion
- Compact footprint
- Expandable to heavier weights
Cons
- Unique block design takes some getting used to
👉 Check Price on Amazon.com (U.S. retailer)
3. NordicTrack Select-A-Weight Dumbbells

Check the handle and adjustment sequence
Handle comfort is individual. Check grip dimensions and hand clearance, and examine how the selectors work while the dumbbell rests in its tray. A comparison photo cannot establish comfort for your hand.
Pros
- Selectable loads within one tray
- Compare grip size with a dumbbell you already use
- Confirm service and replacement-part support in Canada
Cons
- Verify exact variant and current seller inventory
👉 Check Price on Amazon.com (U.S. retailer)
4. ATIVAFIT Adjustable Dumbbells

Compare the price of a complete pair
ATIVAFIT sells different adjustable variants. Compare the selected model’s starting weight, increments and package quantity before treating its headline price as a saving. A single dumbbell should not be price-compared with a pair.
Pros
- Compare total cost for the quantity you need
- Check the actual range of the selected variant
- Useful only if the lowest loads match your exercises
Cons
- Durability has not been independently tested for this guide
👉 Check Price on Amazon.com (U.S. retailer)
Build a shortlist from your exercises
Write down the lightest load you use for an isolation exercise and the heaviest load you use for a compound exercise. A set should cover both, with manageable steps in between. For example, moving from 5 lb to 10 lb doubles the load; a smaller intermediate step may matter more than an impressive maximum.
Measure the setup, not only the weight
Mark out both storage trays and the clearance needed to lift and replace each dumbbell. Include any stand in your room and budget calculation. If the handle assembly stays long at lower weights, consider whether it will obstruct the movements you intend to do.
Compare like-for-like costs
Record whether the listing is for one dumbbell or a pair, included trays, optional stand, expansion kit, shipping and return charges. An illustrative C$300 single weight costs C$600 for two before other charges; it is not cheaper than a C$500 pair on item price alone. These figures are examples, not current offers.
Inspect the mechanism and support
Read the manufacturer’s loading, adjustment and drop restrictions. Confirm warranty service for your country and who pays return shipping. Reject missing labels, damaged selectors or a listing that cannot identify its model. A general brand reputation does not verify an individual used unit.
Frequently asked questions
Which option should I shortlist?
For an expansion plan, investigate the exact PowerBlock generation and compatible kits. For other selector designs, compare NordicTrack and the exact ATIVAFIT variant against your load and space worksheet. We are not naming an overall winner without comparable verified information.
Does a higher maximum weight make a set better?
Only if you need it. Minimum load, step size and movement clearance can be more important for smaller exercises.
Should I buy the original BowFlex 552?
Our previous recommendation is withdrawn because of the recall described above. Identify the exact model and follow the official instructions; a newer replacement series must be evaluated separately.
Our recommendation
Start with a complete-pair budget and your actual exercise loads. Eliminate models that fail the recall, fit, increment or support checks. Then compare the remaining options on total cost. This avoids declaring a product best based only on its brand or highest weight.
Related Articles
- Best Outdoor Fitness Equipment for Kids in Canada
- Best Electrolyte Supplements in Canada (2026)
- Best Fitbit Fitness Trackers for Health & Workout Tracking in 2026
- Best Neck & Back Massagers With Heat for Home Relaxation Under $100
- Best Baby Monitors in Canada (2026)
- Best Baby Carriers in Canada (2026)
- Best High Chairs for Babies in Canada (2026)
- Best Non-Toxic Play Mats for Babies in Canada (2026)



[…] Depending on your routine, you may also want to compare workout gloves for grip and lifting and adjustable dumbbells for home strength training. […]
[…] training plan. Readers building a home routine may find it more useful to begin with our guides to adjustable dumbbells and workout gloves before adding optional […]
[…] basic setup using adjustable dumbbells, a bench and resistance bands may cost less and remain functional without an internet connection. […]
[…] adjustable dumbbells […]